Would That It Make You Happy Correct Grammer

Would That It Make You Happy? Grammar and Usage

The phrase "Would that it make you happy" is grammatically correct, albeit somewhat archaic and formal. It's an example of a subjunctive mood construction expressing a wish or a hope, often tinged with a sense of wistful longing or regret that the wish is unlikely to be fulfilled. Understanding its grammar and proper usage is key to employing it effectively.

Understanding the Subjunctive Mood:

The subjunctive mood is a verb form used to express wishes, suggestions, demands, or hypothetical situations. It's less common in modern English than in older forms of the language, but it still appears in certain contexts. In this phrase, "would" isn't used as a past tense auxiliary verb, but rather as a modal verb expressing a hypothetical or conditional action. "That it make you happy" is the subjunctive clause, using the base form of the verb "make" instead of the usual "makes" found in indicative sentences.

Alternative Phrasings:

While grammatically sound, "Would that it make you happy" might sound stiff or overly formal in casual conversation. More contemporary alternatives include:

• I wish it would make you happy. (This is a much more common and natural way to express the same sentiment.)
• I hope it makes you happy. (Simpler and more direct.)
• I would be happy if it made you happy. (Slightly more verbose but clearer.)
• May it bring you happiness. (More formal, but less wistful.)

Context and Tone:

The appropriateness of using "Would that it make you happy" depends heavily on context. It might be suitable in:

• Literary works: The phrase's archaic nature lends itself well to creating a specific atmosphere or tone in novels, poems, or plays.
• Formal speeches or writings: In very formal settings, the phrase might convey a sense of gravitas or polite formality.
• Expressions of heartfelt, but perhaps unattainable, wishes: The subjunctive nature implies a longing for something that may not be easily achieved.

Examples in Context:

• "Would that it make you happy," he sighed, watching her walk away. (This uses the phrase effectively to convey a sense of longing and regret.)
• "I offer this gift, hoping it will bring joy. Would that it make you happy," the old woman said gently. (Here, the phrase adds a formal, almost prayer-like quality.)

In Conclusion:

"Would that it make you happy" is a grammatically correct phrase, but its archaic and formal nature limits its practicality in everyday speech. While its use in specific contexts can add a unique stylistic flair, simpler alternatives are generally preferred for clarity and naturalness in most situations. Understanding the subjunctive mood, however, helps appreciate the nuances of this slightly antiquated but perfectly valid expression.