Fallout 4 Should I Kill Skinny Malone

Fallout 4: Should You Kill Skinny Malone? A Comprehensive Guide

Should you kill Skinny Malone in Fallout 4? This seemingly simple question sparks heated debate among players. This guide explores the ramifications of this decision, examining the pros and cons, and ultimately helping you decide what's best for your playthrough. This isn't just about a single character; it touches on morality, faction loyalty, and the overall Fallout 4 experience.

Skinny Malone, the seemingly harmless (but definitely shifty) bartender at the Third Rail, is embroiled in a complex web of Diamond City intrigue. His actions and connections impact several quests and relationships, making the choice of whether to eliminate him a significant one.

The Arguments for Killing Skinny Malone

• Justice for Trudy: Many players feel killing Skinny Malone is justified due to his involvement in Trudy's disappearance and likely demise. His callous disregard for her safety and subsequent lies make him a prime candidate for a swift and decisive end. This appeals to players seeking a more morally righteous playthrough, dispensing justice where the law fails. This is a common reason players engage with the game's darker side, eliminating those who have wronged others.

• Protecting Diamond City: Eliminating Skinny Malone might seem to improve the security and stability of Diamond City. While not directly confirmed, his shady dealings could potentially destabilize the already fragile peace of this settlement. This choice aligns with players who prioritize the safety and well-being of Diamond City's inhabitants above all else. Players concerned with settlement management and overall stability in the Commonwealth often consider this.

• Reward for the Railroad: While not explicitly stated, eliminating Skinny Malone can be seen as a favor to the Railroad, given his association with questionable elements. This action aligns with players committed to the Railroad storyline and aims to strengthen their ties with the faction. This is a common consideration for players invested in the narrative surrounding the Railroad and their fight against the Institute.

The Arguments Against Killing Skinny Malone

• Potential for Missed Quests and Information: Killing Skinny Malone prevents access to certain quests and valuable information later in the game. This might mean missing unique items, experiences, or even alternative paths to completing other missions. Players interested in exploring all aspects of the game world and completing every quest line should consider this carefully.

• Moral Ambiguity: While Skinny Malone's actions are questionable, outright murder isn't always the answer. Players seeking a more nuanced and less violent approach to the game might find killing him morally objectionable, even if his actions warrant punishment. This perspective aligns with players who prefer less morally grey gameplay choices.

• Impact on Reputation and Relationships: Killing Skinny Malone will negatively impact your relationships with certain factions or individuals within Diamond City. This could lead to lost opportunities or even conflict later in the game. This consideration is key for players focused on building positive relationships and navigating the complex social dynamics of the Fallout 4 world.

The Verdict: It Depends on Your Playthrough

Ultimately, the decision of whether to kill Skinny Malone rests entirely on your preferred playstyle and moral compass. There is no objectively "right" answer. Consider your alignment with different factions, your approach to completing quests, and your personal sense of justice when making this important choice in your Fallout 4 adventure. Careful consideration of these factors will lead you to a choice that feels authentic to your character and your overall gaming experience. Remember, the consequences of your actions will ripple through the game in subtle and significant ways.